When you’re hiring finance talent for a pre-IPO company, there’s plenty to get excited about. You can see what someone could build with you, and they may share that enthusiasm. As the conversation gets closer to an offer, though, they have to consider what they’d be giving up.

That’s where “golden handcuffs” and “cold feet” come into the conversation. Golden handcuffs are the financial benefits that make leaving difficult, such as unvested stock or an approaching bonus. Alongside those benefits comes the comfort of working with a boss they trust. On the other hand, cold feet is the hesitation that can appear as accepting your offer becomes a real possibility. Suddenly, your IPO plans feel personal, and the person who sounded enthusiastic last week needs more time.

You can make that decision easier by giving them room to explain what’s holding them back. Start with what they’d leave behind, then make your offer easy to evaluate and discuss at home. Even people who build financial models for a living occasionally need to close the laptop and talk things through. So how do you give a great finance professional enough confidence to say yes?

Understand What They Would Be Leaving Behind

Before adjusting your offer, ask what would make the timing of a move workable. A simple question opens the conversation: “Are there any upcoming compensation dates you’d like us to consider?” Give them room to explain what they’re comfortable sharing, then discuss what they would need from your package to make a move possible.

The answer gives you something concrete to work with. An approaching vesting date may make a later start attractive. A bonus payment could raise a similar question, although the person should check the eligibility conditions before relying on that date. Schwab’s guidance on leaving an employer explains that the treatment of equity depends on the relevant plan and award terms.

There can be a personal plan behind that money, too. In Schwab’s 2025 US survey, 50% of stock plan participants saw equity compensation as contributing to their retirement goals. Your finalist may have already assigned their shares a job in their future. Asking them to walk away means asking them to reconsider that plan.

Once you understand the timing, you can discuss options your company can support. A later start may resolve the concern. Where appropriate, an approved signing payment could offset compensation they would forfeit. Explain any repayment conditions at the same time, so the person can evaluate the whole arrangement without discovering an unwelcome surprise after accepting.

Be straightforward about the limits of that discussion. If you have flexibility on the start date, say so. If the package is fixed, explain that before they spend another evening recalculating. You’re both making a decision, and knowing where there’s room to move keeps the conversation fair to everyone involved.

Keep the conversation open to reasons that have little to do with compensation. They may feel guilty about leaving a manager who backed them. You can respect that relationship and discuss a sensible handover. Calling their current job “too comfortable” is unlikely to make anyone feel understood, especially when they’ve worked hard to earn that comfort.

As you listen, pay attention to whether the concern involves timing or something your offer cannot accommodate. That’ll give you a realistic starting point for discussing the opportunity ahead.

Make Your Pre-IPO Offer Easier to Evaluate

A finance leader may understand equity exceptionally well and still need detailed answers about your particular company. Give them access to the terms and someone who can explain them. They should feel comfortable asking a question twice, especially when the answer affects a decision they’ll live with for years.

Start with a short written explanation alongside the formal documents. State the base salary and explain how the bonus is determined. Then describe the equity award separately, including any approval still required. Keeping those components distinct makes it easier to understand which parts of the package they can rely on and which depend on future outcomes.

Stock options give someone the right to buy shares at a set price within a specified period. Restricted stock units usually promise shares once the award’s conditions are met, with delivery timing set by the plan. Before they accept, talk them through those terms, including what happens to their equity if they leave the company.

Next, talk about when they might be able to turn equity into cash. Your plans for an IPO deserve a candid explanation, including the dependencies that remain. Discuss what staying private for longer would mean for their award. An IPO can also be followed by restrictions on selling, while private secondary sales typically require company approval, as Nasdaq Private Market explains.

If you illustrate potential equity value, identify the assumptions behind the figures. Show the applicable costs alongside them, and allow time for questions about less favorable outcomes. Invite the professional to review the documents with their own advisor. Someone joining your finance team should be able to examine a financial proposition closely without feeling they’ve spoiled the mood.

Of course, they’re accepting a job as well as a compensation package. Explain the decisions they would own and how they would work with the founder. If they’re concerned about having a voice, ask the founder to discuss a real occasion when financial advice changed a business decision. A specific example gives them something to assess.

If the role offers broader responsibility, connect that opportunity to something they told you they want to do. Someone eager to build a team should understand the hiring budget available to them. That makes the career benefit concrete enough to weigh alongside the financial commitments they’re considering.

You can also discuss what the role would involve if the IPO timetable changes. The person needs to see a job they would still want while the business works toward its next milestone. Once those answers are available, they can consider whether the opportunity fits their ambitions and the life they intend to maintain outside work.

Give Finance Talent the Access and Time to Decide

When someone goes quiet, contact them with a question they can answer comfortably: “What would you still like to understand before making a decision?” You’re giving them permission to raise the concern they may have struggled to phrase. If they need another conversation, agree on whom they should speak with and what that discussion should address.

A peer can be particularly reassuring here. Offer an introduction to a finance professional who made a comparable move, ideally someone who joined your business from an established company. Let them speak privately and ask follow-up questions. Encourage a candid account of the adjustment, including anything the person wishes they had understood before joining. A polished testimonial leaves little room for the questions your finalist actually has.

Keep the introduction relevant to their concern. Someone wondering how the founder responds to disagreement needs access to people who have worked through it. If they’re trying to picture the workload, a colleague can describe an ordinary week and the periods that demand more. This gives them a fuller view of the job they’re considering.

Then give them space to discuss the decision at home. They choose whom to involve and how much to share. A written recap means they can explain the offer without trying to reconstruct a conversation from memory. Your enthusiasm may be infectious, but their partner gets to ask practical questions without having sat through the company presentation.

Agree on a decision date together once the outstanding information is available. Explain any real business deadline, and ask whether the proposed timing gives them enough room. You can keep the process moving with a scheduled conversation while allowing them to think between calls.

During that time, make each follow-up earn its place. Send the answer you promised or confirm that a requested discussion has been arranged. When a concern remains unresolved, name who will address it and when. Repeatedly asking whether they have decided adds very little to the decision itself.

Sometimes, those conversations lead to the conclusion that the move doesn’t fit. Respect that answer. The way you handle it tells them how you treat people when a conversation ends differently from how you hoped.

Finance talent can commit with greater confidence when the opportunity fits the commitments they already have. Give people enough information to examine the offer and enough room to decide how it fits their lives. The trust you build through those conversations can become the foundation of your working relationship, starting well before their first day and continuing into the difficult decisions you’ll eventually face together.

Hiring a finance leader for your pre-IPO company?

Altitude Search Group specializes in finance and accounting leadership searches. We support both sides through the conversations that lead to a confident decision.

Talk to us about your next finance hire.

Share this with a colleague preparing to make a senior offer.